Occasions
  • Birthday gifts for women

    Birthday Gifts

  • Anniversary gifts for her

    Anniversary Gifts

  • housewarming gifts for her

    Housewarming Gifts

  • Graduation gifts for her

    Graduation

  • Drinkware
  • Personalized tumblers for women

    Tumblers

  • Personalized wine glasses

    Wine

  • Personalized water bottles

    Water Bottles

  • Personalized Drinkware for Women

    Drinkware Fun

  • Accessories
  • Personalized necklaces

    Necklaces

  • Personalized bracelets

    Bracelets

  • Personalized makeup bags

    Makeup Bags

  • Personalized weekender bags

    Travel Bags

  • Home
  • Personalized blankets

    Blankets & Throws

  • Personalized charcuterie boards

    Charcuterie Boards

  • Personalized signs for the home

    Personalized Signs

  • Personalized home decor for her

    Decor

  • Personalized Tooth Fairy Keepsake Box

    Free Personalization — Crafted by hand in Monroe, CT
    FREE PERSONALIZATION

    Make it theirs

    Box Color
    0/24

    Engraved in script under the mailbox. We engrave exactly what you type.

    0/150

    Optional. Up to 150 characters, so two or three lines is fine. Leave blank for a plain inside lid.

    Delivery truck icon Ships Within 2 Business Days
    Free Personalization Icon Gift Message Available at Checkout
    Gift icon 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

    A Tooth Fairy Express mailbox on the lid, your child's name beneath it, and a safe place for every lost tooth.

    • Tooth Fairy Express mailbox and smiling winged tooth engraved on the lid with your child's name
    • Optional message engraved inside the lid, up to 150 characters
    • Cherry, black or burl finish
    • Spanish cedar lining and internal locking hinges
    • 9 by 8.5 by 2.25 inches, room for every baby tooth plus the notes left behind

    Losing a tooth is a very big night when you are six. This box turns it into a tradition: the tooth goes into a small container inside, the note from the Tooth Fairy goes in beside it, and the mailbox on the lid tells everyone whose box it is.

    Years later it is the box you open to find every first tooth, the tiny letters written in glitter pen and the coins nobody spent. The message inside the lid is yours to write, so it can come from you or from the Tooth Fairy herself.

    How to Personalize

    1. Choose the finish: cherry, black or burl.
    2. Type your child's name for the lid.
    3. Add a message for the inside of the lid, or leave it plain.

    We engrave exactly what you type, so read it back before you add it to your cart. Our team laser engraves every keepsake box by hand in Monroe, Connecticut.

    Product Details

    • Materials: solid wood with a Spanish cedar lining
    • Dimensions: 9 by 8.5 by 2.25 inches
    • Finishes: cherry, black or burl, with the engraving showing in a light tone
    • Design: Tooth Fairy Express mailbox with a smiling winged tooth and sparkles
    • Features: internal locking hinges
    • Personalization: child's name up to 24 characters, optional inside message up to 150
    Custom Designs
    Free Personalization
    On All Products
    Trusted By Thousands
    Trusted By Thousands
    100,000+ Happy Customers Across Our Family of Brands
    Free Shipping
    Free Shipping
    On Orders Over $100

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How should I store teeth in the box?
    Let each tooth dry completely, then put it in its own small container or bag before it goes in. A loose tooth slips into the corners, and one that is not fully dry can grow mold.
    Can the message inside the lid come from the Tooth Fairy?
    Yes. Write it in her voice, for example: A tiny tooth, a little cheer, proof the Tooth Fairy has been here! We engrave it exactly as you type it. Leave the field blank for a plain inside lid.
    Can two siblings share one box?
    The lid is laid out for one name. Two short names fit on the name line, such as Mia and Leo, but a box for each child keeps every child's teeth and notes separate.
    Is personalization/engraving really free?

    Yes! Every item includes free personalization. Just enter your details on the product page and we'll customize it before shipping.

    How long does shipping take?

    Many products ship within 1-2 business days from our facility in Monroe, CT and typically arrive within a few business days depending on your location. Some products can take longer in production, so for the most accurate shipping time on this item, see the estimate displayed beneath the add to cart button. Expedited shipping options are also available at checkout.

    What is your return policy?

    Because every item is custom-made and personalized just for you, we cannot accept returns on personalized items. However, if your item arrives damaged or with an error we made, we will replace it at no cost. Just reach out to us at support@groovygirlgifts.com, or via live chat during our business hours, and provide your order number and a photo and we'll take care of it.

    Can I cancel or change my order?

    Reach out to us as soon as possible at support@groovygirlgifts.com, or via live chat during our business hours. Once an order is placed and paid for we cannot guarantee any changes, but we will do our best to accommodate updates to personalization details, shipping address, or product selection before production begins. Once production starts, changes are not possible.

    Crafted With Care

    From design to delivery, our skilled production team at Groovy Girl Gifts works tirelessly behind the scenes to craft personalized gifts that create lasting memories.

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 201 reviews
    94%
    (188)
    4%
    (9)
    0%
    (1)
    1%
    (2)
    0%
    (1)
    B
    Besiana Jangozi
    Absolutely amazing

    I ordered a keepsake for a newborn and it was absolutely perfect.The quality was very good and the gift was so thoughtful and special. The baby's parents love it so much. I am very happy with my purchase and I would definitely recommend Groovy Guy Gifts!

    J
    Jennifer Thompson
    Wonderful box and quality!!

    My son-in-law newly graduated from the DC police academy and loves this as a gift!! We personalized it with an inside graving as well that turned out beautifully!!

    L
    Lorene Tolman
    Customer Service

    Product is beautiful and customer service was outstanding!

    T
    Tanya Murray
    My son loved it’

    I got the engraved box for my son for his wedding gift and he loved the inscription inside

    J
    James E Dougherty
    Very nice

    Jewelry box is beautiful, nicely made

    S
    Sue Pedana
    Keepsake Box

    The keepsake box did not disappoint!! Beautifully made! Thrilled with purchase!

    A
    Alisha Blair
    Amazing!

    I ordered this box for my husband for our 10 year anniversary. I forgot to add something in the text and i emailed immediately. They responded within an hour and was able to add it! Customer service was amazing and everyone was so friendly. The box was finished and at my door within a week! The box was absolutely beautiful and was well done!! They have made me a forever customer and would recommend them to anyone!!

    b
    belinda Thurman

    Belinda

    M
    Margaret Albanese
    Keepsake box

    Absolutely beautiful !!

    J
    Joseph Mendoza
    Amazing!

    My wife absolutely loved the gift!

    Mobile Image

    100,000
    Customers Served

    We combine our passion for crafting memorable gifts with a commitment to exceptional service. Our dedicated team in Monroe, Connecticut ensures every personalized gift exceeds your expectations

    About Us

    As Seen On

    Globe