20 Best First Mother's Day Gifts for New Moms

Mother's Day is a special day to celebrate the amazing moms in our lives. But this year, there is an even more special reason to shower the new mom in your life with love and appreciation. It's her first Mother's Day! This is a momentous occasion that deserves to be commemorated with unforgettable gifts. Whether she's a first-time mom or recently welcomed a new addition to the family, finding the perfect gift can be challenging. 

But fear not, we have compiled a list of 20 best first Mother's Day gifts that are sure to make her day extra special. From sentimental keepsakes to practical items, these gift ideas are perfect for the new mom and her precious bundle of joy. 

So, let's make this first Mother's Day a memorable one for the new mom and her baby with these thoughtful and heartwarming gifts.

1. Blissful Mom Spa Retreat Gift Set

Price: Buy Now for $69.99

The Blissful Mom Spa Retreat Gift Set is the ultimate indulgence package, meticulously curated to provide an extraordinary woman with everything she needs for a moment of relaxation and rejuvenation.

This sweet first Mother's Day gift set includes a variety of spa essentials such as a cloud blue headband, lavender bath bomb, rejuvenating face masks, and fragrant bath teas, along with nourishing cream and revitalizing under eye patches.

2. Custom Embroidered Throw Blanket

Price: Buy Now for $52.99

This cozy throw blanket is a warm and stylish way to celebrate new moms. Made from 100% premium, skin-friendly acrylic, it’s super soft, lightweight, and warm—perfect for snuggling up with a new baby. 

Choose from three blanket colors, customize it with a patch, and select from a variety of patch colors and designs to make it truly unique. Measuring 50” x 67”, this is a gift for new moms that adds both comfort and personalization, making it a great choice for a loved one on her first Mother's Day.

3. Personalized Baby Keepsake Sign

Price: Buy Now for $44.99

Make her first Mother’s Day unforgettable with this personalized Baby Keepsake Sign. 

Engraved with her baby’s name, birth details, and location, it’s a heartfelt tribute to her new journey. With a gentle LED glow and timeless design, it’s a gift she’ll cherish forever.

4. Mother's Day Memories Puzzle

Price: Buy Now for $59.99

Turn a special moment into a fun activity with this custom photo puzzle. Upload a picture, add text, and include the sender’s name for a heartfelt touch. 

The puzzle measures 8.25" x 11.5" when assembled and consists of 100 sturdy cardboard pieces. It comes in a beautifully engraved wooden gift box, making it a keepsake a loved one will treasure. This is one of the best Mother's Day gifts for new moms who love creating memories.

5. Mother's Love Song Keepsake

Price: Buy Now for $39.99

The Mother's Love Song Keepsake is a uniquely sentimental item that immortalizes a favorite melody within an elegantly designed 5” x 7” song light box.

Crafted from high-quality wood and acrylic, these personalized new mom Mother's Day gifts display a cherished photo alongside the title of a meaningful song, creating a beautiful tribute to the loving relationship between a mother and her child.

This first Mother's Day gift allows you to add a photo, song name, and a personal message, serves as a melodic journey that lights up with love.

6. Cozy Comfort Gift Set

Price: Buy Now for $119.99

This beautifully curated gift set is perfect for new moms who deserve relaxation. It comes in a handcrafted cedar crate, measuring 13" x 9.75" x 6", which can be personalized with up to 50 characters. 

Inside, she’ll find four premium tea sachets in flavors like Calming Tea, English Breakfast, Jasmine Green Tea, and Rooibos Chai. The set also includes a 16 oz gloss-finish ceramic mug in six designs and six colors, a faux leather journal with 112 lined pages and a black satin bookmark, and a cozy acrylic throw blanket in khaki.

7. Memories Etched in Wood Frame

Price: Buy Now for $24.99

The Memories Etched in Wood Frame is a beautifully crafted picture frame made from genuine Red Alder wood, designed to capture and cherish moments of maternal affection.

Available in two sizes to accommodate either a 4” x 6” or a 5” x 7” photograph, these no-fail presents for new moms feature a warm, light brown color that adds a cozy feel to any room. The frame can be displayed either horizontally or vertically, equipped with two sawtooth hangers and an easel for versatile placement.

8. Maternal Blossoms of Love Photo Frame

Price: Buy Now for $34.99

The Maternal Blossoms of Love Photo Frame is a beautifully designed keepsake that celebrates the enduring bond between a mother and her children.

Crafted from a blend of natural wood and translucent acrylic, this unique first Mother's Day gift is not only visually appealing but also highly functional.  This allows the frame to illuminate, highlighting the "Blooming In Love" inscription and the vibrant flowers associated with each child's name.

9. Funny Mom Custom Tumbler

Price: Buy Now for $34.99

This personalized tumbler is a fun and practical gift for any multitasking mom. Upload a photo, choose a color, and add custom text to make it unique. 

Made from 20 oz stainless steel, it features double-wall insulation to keep drinks hot or cold for hours. The eye-catching UV print celebrates hardworking moms and is perfect for home, work, or on the go. It’s an ideal gift for new moms who are ready to enjoy every sip.

10. Personalized New Mommy Footprint Art

Price: Buy Now for $28.00

Celebrate the bond between mom and her new baby with Personalized New Mommy Footprint Art.

Printed on 88lb Matte Fine Art Paper using Epson Ultra Chrome Pro Ink, these last-minute Mother's Day gift ideas become a cherished keepsake, capturing the tiny footprints of her little one.

Choose the perfect size and personalize it with a special message, making it a unique addition to the collection of first Mother's Day gifts.

11. Our First Mother's Day Mug

Price: Buy Now for $12.99

Capture the essence of this milestone with the "Our First Mother's Day Mug," a beautifully crafted Ceramic keepsake that celebrates the bond between mom and her new baby. Available in 11oz and 15oz sizes, this mug can be personalized with the names of the mother and baby, making it a unique addition to our collection of thoughtful Mother's Day gifts. 

Whether she's sipping her morning coffee or evening tea, these great new mom Mother's Day gift ideas serve as a daily reminder of her first Mother's Day—a special moment shared between parents and their precious daughter or son.

Related: Sip with sentiment using our Personalized Coffee Mugs, a perfect blend of warmth and style for your cherished daily rituals.

12. Mom's Personalized Leather Wristlet

Price: Buy Now for $44.99

This stylish leather wristlet is a great Mother's Day gift for a mom on the go. Choose from 8 colors and 12 birth flower designs, then personalize it with her name or initials. 

Measuring 7.5” x 4”, it features 12+1 ID card slots, compartments for cash and receipts, a secure snap closure, and a detachable wrist strap. This is the one thing every loved one needs to keep essentials organized in style.

13. First Mothers Day Card

Price: Buy Now for $5.99

Complement your gift with a heartfelt First Mother's Day Card, where beautiful text resonates with the profound experience of new motherhood. 

This card isn't just about words; it's a testament to the nights spent awake, taking care of the little one, and the unforgettable journey that moms, especially new moms and new parents, embark on. Let this card be a reminder that even if things go wrong, her love and dedication never go unnoticed.

14. First Mother's Day Picture Frame

Price: Buy Now for $24.99

Crafted from the finest vegan leather and durable glass, our First Mother's Day Picture Frame is the epitome of elegance and kindness. 

Available in a selection of colors, it can be personalized, offering a unique way to cherish memories with your little ones. This frame isn't just a new mom gift; it's a testament to the joy and love shared between mommy and baby, capturing smiles and moments of fun.

15. Happy First Mothers Day Soy Candle

Price: Buy Now for $8.75

Illuminate her world this First Mother's Day with a Soy Candle, designed to fill her space with warmth and serenity. Choose a scent that resonates with her unique essence, offering a tranquil retreat from the new challenges of motherhood. 

This soy candle, a symbol of your glowing appreciation for her first steps into motherhood, stands out among Mother's Day gifts as a beacon of relaxation. 

16. Baby and Mommy Names Cute Giraffes Shirt

Price: Buy Now for $10.27

For the family eager to wear their hearts on their sleeves, our Baby and Mommy Names Cute Giraffes Shirt is the perfect mother's day gift. 

Personalized to feature both the mother and baby's names amidst an adorable giraffe motif, these shirts are available in sizes ranging from newborn to adult XL and come in soft pastel or bold primary colors.

Ideal for memorable family photos, this new mom gift wraps comfort and sentiment into one, making it a standout among first-time Mother's Day gift ideas.

17. Mother & Baby Necklace Pendant

Price: Buy Now for $99.99

Celebrate the bond of new motherhood with the "I Am Loved Diamond Mother & Baby Necklace Pendant" in Sterling Silver & 14K Rose Gold.

These last-minute Mother's Day gifts symbolize the unbreakable connection between a mother and her child, making it a top pick among first Mother's Day gift ideas. Its sparkling diamonds capture the joy and pride of giving birth, serving as a lasting reminder of the love and fun that motherhood brings. 

A thoughtful present from a husband to his wife or a self-gift for new moms, this necklace ensures every mommy can wear a smile close to her heart.

18. Acrylic Block Puzzle Piece

Price: Buy Now for $6.99

Gift a symbol of unity and love with the Acrylic Block Puzzle Piece. Crafted from clear, durable acrylic, this piece showcases beautiful text themed around love, making it an exquisite addition to any house.

It is an ideal gift for women, especially new moms or a friend celebrating her first Mother's Day. This first Mother's Day gift not only stands as a unique decoration but also represents the interlocking lives of family members.

19. Chocolate Gift Baskets

Price: Buy Now for $35.99

Imagine the delight on her face when she unwraps a luxurious Chocolate Gift Basket, meticulously assembled to celebrate her first Mother's Day. Filled with 25 handcrafted milk chocolate cookies, each symbolizing an hour of the day she dedicates to her new role, it's a sweet tribute to her unwavering love and care. 

Beyond just chocolates, this best first Mother's Day gift basket can be adorned with flowers and healthy snacks, providing that much-needed break for new moms.

It is a thoughtful way to acknowledge her efforts, bringing friends and family together in her cozy house, and ensuring she feels appreciated and pampered on this special day.

20. Pregnancy Gift Box for Moms-to-be

Price: Buy Now for $65.00

Pamper the expecting mother with Pregnancy Gift Box for Moms-to-be. This elegant set includes organic nipple balm, belly oil, a soothing candle, a mom journal, lavender soap, foot salt, and more.

Each item is chosen to offer comfort and relaxation during pregnancy. The chic gift box can be personalized with the recipient's name and includes a custom greeting card, making it an ideal gift for any mom-to-be.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What should I do for my mom's first Mother's Day?

A1: For your mom's first Mother's Day, consider creating a heartfelt and personalized experience. You could prepare a delicious breakfast, write a heartfelt letter expressing your gratitude, or organize a family photo session to capture the special moments of this milestone.

Q2: What do you buy a first time mother?

A2: When buying for a first-time mother, consider thoughtful and practical gifts. A personalized jewelry, a diaper bag, a belt bag, a five-year journal, a photo book, a spa voucher for relaxation, or a customized baby photo album can make for sentimental and cherished presents to commemorate her journey into motherhood.

Q3: What should I do for my wife on her first Mother's Day?

A3: On your wife's first Mother's Day, make her feel extra special. Consider organizing a spa day, cooking a delightful meal, or giving her a personalized gift, like a piece of jewelry with the baby's birthstone. Show appreciation for her new role and the love and care she provides.

Q4: What do most moms want for Mother's Day?

A4: Most moms appreciate thoughtful and meaningful gestures. Consider a day off from chores, a homemade meal, or a spa day to let her relax. Personalized gifts, such as custom jewelry or a heartfelt letter, often hold great sentimental value. Ultimately, the key is to recognize her individual preferences and make her feel loved and appreciated.

Related: 

Explore the charm of heartfelt gestures with our Personalized Mother's Day Gifts, turning moments into cherished memories.

Elevate your gifting game with curated Gift Sets For Women, offering a perfect blend of luxury, style, and thoughtful surprises.

Discover heartwarming Mother's Day Gift Ideas that blend sentimentality with style, ensuring a day as special as she is.